Homemade with Heart

M & S Bakery

Small-batch sweets, big-batch love — baked fresh by two best friends.

Browse the Menu Our Story
Scroll to explore
M & S Bakery baking setup with freshly made treats
Madison and Sadie, co-founders of M & S Bakery
Our Story

Two best friends,
one delicious dream.

Madison and Sadie have been inseparable since the first grade — bonded first over movie night and craft playdates, and eventually over something even sweeter: baking. Weekends at each other's houses meant flour-dusted countertops, lopsided frosting attempts, and too many taste tests to count.

Years later, when life sent them down different roads, the kitchen was always what brought them back together. It felt like home. It felt like them. So they made a decision: stop just baking for fun, and start baking for everyone else too.

M & S Bakery was born from that simple idea — that really good homemade treats, made with real care and real ingredients, can make any occasion feel a little more special. Every item that leaves our kitchen is something we'd proudly set on our own tables.

Madison Co-founder & Head Baker
+
Sadie Co-founder & Head Baker
Make It Yours

Customization Options

Every order is built around you. Mix and match any of the options below — just let us know your picks at checkout.

Cake & Cupcake Flavors

Choose your base for any cake, cupcake, or cookie order.

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Red Velvet
  • Lemon
  • Orange

Frosting

Pick your base, then choose a flavor — or mix and match across tiers.

Base

  • Buttercream
  • Cream Cheese

Flavors

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Raspberry
  • Lemon
  • Blueberry
  • Orange
  • Strawberry

Toppings

Finish off your order with one or more toppings for that extra touch.

  • Mini M&M's
  • Chocolate Chips
  • Fresh Berries of Your Choice
  • Chocolate Drizzle
  • Powdered Sugar

Colors

We can match any color scheme — whether it's a birthday palette, wedding theme, or your favorite color. Just let us know and we'll make it happen.

Any color, any combination — you dream it, we'll do it.

Don't see what you're looking for? Just ask. We love a challenge and are happy to work with special requests, dietary needs, and creative ideas.

Custom Orders

Place Your Order

Tell us what you're dreaming of and we'll make it happen. All orders are made fresh to your specifications. Please place orders at least a week in advance.

01 Your Info

02 Items & Quantities

Subtotal —
Estimated Total $0.00

03 Order Details

We'll reach out within 24 hours to confirm your order and discuss details.

Secure Your Order

Payment

Payments must be received within 48 hours of order request to secure your spot.

Pay via Venmo

Send payment directly to our Venmo account. Include your name and order date in the note.

Open Venmo
Venmo QR Code for M & S Bakery — scan to pay SCAN TO PAY

Scan QR Code

Scan the code with your phone's camera or Venmo app to go directly to our payment page. Fast and easy.

1

Submit your order request using the form above

2

We'll confirm details and send your total

3

Send payment via Venmo within 48 hours

4

We bake, you celebrate 🎉